Tuesday, March 13, 2012

Recipe Recap: Malted Chocolate Chip Cookies

I’m trying to find a go-to chocolate chip cookie recipe.  There are still a few out there that get rave reviews, like the one from the NY Times or this one from Cook’s Illustrated.  I like the latter because it uses melted butter so I don’t have to worry about planning ahead to have my butter softened.  I actually used this recipe to make a cookie in bar form and it was quite tasty, but since they were bars and not cookies, I can’t accurately judge the recipe.

Anyway, those two recipes are still on my list.  I decided to try this cookie with malted milk and Hershey’s Syrup a couple weekends ago.  I had high hopes for it and the flavor lived up to my expectations but the texture, the shape, the look just weren’t right.

See?  They turned out flat.

IMG_3169

However, they retained their chewiness so all was not lost.

IMG_3165

I used a mix of semi-sweet and milk chocolate chips, which I have to say was an inspired move on my part.  I may make all my chocolate chip cookies this way from now on.

IMG_3171

The recipe I used was based on one from Taste of Home.  The original recipe used shortening instead of  butter so I’m going to try these cookies again with butter-flavored Crisco and see how that works.

IMG_3166

Any volunteers for guinea pig duty?  It doesn’t pay much, but I think you’ll be happy with the benefits package.

IMG_3170

1 comment:

McMom said...

The mix of chip flavors is always a good move...and you may find the flavored Cisco may make them puffer than the butter. I always had trouble with butter making them flat.... Go for it! Mc Mom